Since using web forums I learned not to take stuff too literally. Face to face with someone, their manner & inflexions put a slant on what they say. Here, print is absolute. After a while you get to know where people are coming from & you take what they say accordingly.
We all use the bikes differently & what works for one won't necessarily work for another. But often people assume that their experience is the only valid viewpoint. If it works for me how can it not work for someone else? To me some tyres are "crap" - they're not that bad - (ever tried pneumants???) - but they cause me problems for the use I put the bike to so I don't like them, when I can have something more suitable. That's what I compare them with.
English is not the first language of some members & some subtlety is probably lost...
Another thing is people (me inc.) readily voice judgements about how good something is w/o ever having tried anything else.
FWIW I like the Ohlins steering damper. I never liked dampers before, even cutting of the mounting brkt on one Tonti frame. Like Mike, I felt that if you needed a damper then there was something more fundamental that you weren't sorting, either with the bike or with your riding. These were ol friction type ones. On Scura I kept it backed off for the first few k miles. Now I keep it set about half way & it does just what Ratchethack describes above, improves the feel of the bike. Dunno wether it's better or worse than any other quality hydraulic damper but it works for me, it has very subtle, effective adjustment from zero & looks & feels very nicely made.
KB