Come off it Ratchet, we're not allowing you that! **The trouble with yours is that it appears like it's trying to be something, while still looking like a big lump of carpet underlay. The 'quality' thing about the inner tube ones is that they are what they are, good honest functional hacks, without trying to look like factory product while falling short of the mark.
In the mud catching dept. either Guzzi produces a proper solution, or it's gotta be flappy rubber tube. I was trying to remember who used the cut-up pig-feed bucket to make one?? That's close to acceptable.
I must say, I'd like to see a decent home made hugger using an everyday object.
**warning, I could be talking , y'know